Transitio n BC COALITION OF PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES N0V7DEC. 1997 Aging and Disability Aging with a Spinal Cord injury Planning with Representation Agreements AIDS and Aging Latimer Decision Shocks Community $1000 Winners More $1000 Winners play at Planet Bingo where more $1000 games are played 27,000 Square Feet A virtual "bingo world" of fast-paced, multi-patterned paper and electronic games - 3 spacious floors housing the latest bingo enhancements, SuperStar, Personal Play and Club Keno. 62 Charities Including this Organization - Working Together to Benefit Everyone. Cover photo, by David Low, of his grandmother transition is published eight times per year by, the Transition Publication Society. Founding Editor Richard A. Watson: Editor AnnVrlak Contributing Editor Geoff McMurphy Layout in this issue Letters to the Editor....................................................... Editorial by Tina Matysiak............................................................. Feature Cover Design Geoff McMurchy Research/Proofreading Eleanor Pasholko Data Input Teresa Kubaseck-Berry Alternate Formats Val Stapleton Mailout PusHPA Patel Carol Dixon Steve Wong; ; Mark Rogen Voice Recording Eleanor Pasholko Partial funding for Transition is provided by Human Resources Development Canada, Thanks also to our sponsors, advertisers, members and subscribers., We welcome articles, graphics, creative writing, et al (maximum length for articles should bel 000 words). The editors reserve the right to edit material. Please send material to: Transition Publication Society c/o BC Coalition of People with Disabilities 204-456 W. B roadway Vancouver, BC V5Y1R3 875-0188 ‘TTY 875-8835 Fax 875-9227 Advocacy Access 872-1278 Canadian Publications Mail Product Sales Agreements No. 0507148 S AIDS and Aging by Tom Mountford.......................................................... Latimer Decision Shocks Community 1 7 BCACLand BCCPD....................................................... Deaf Community Wins at Supreme Court.................. Action Needed to Protect Seniors 9 by Scott Adams.............................................................. Parents Launch Human Rights Action by Carol Walshe............................................................. 11 Climbing the Mountain of Aging by Barbara Alldritt........................................................... 17 Planning a Safe and Secure Future............................ 24 Aging with a Spinal Cord Injury by Coleen Heenan......................................................... Planning with a Representation Agreement.............. News&Notice s Travel Info..................................................................... Changes to CPP........................................................... Government Backtracks on Education Cuts............. Sunnyhill Health Centre for Children......................... International News....................................................... Inclusion Resource Network Closes.......................... Board Members Retire................................................. 22 Job Placement Program.............................................. Classified Ad............................................................... Editorial Note: The views and opinions expressed within the pages of Transition are not necessarily those held by the total membership or Board of Directors of the B.C. Coalition of People with Disabilities. The material presented herein is meant to be thought-provoking and to promote dialogue. Transition is your opportunity to share information and to introduce issues which you feel should be brought to the attention of the disabled community and the general public. It is also an opportunity for disabled individuals to display creative talent. November/December 1997 Transition ______ letters Thanks to Massie Dear Editor: In September 1997, Margo Massie stepped down from the BCCPD Board of Direc­ tors after eleven years of service. I would like to wish Margo well in her new life as she takes up residence in Victoria. As a fellow advocate and past board member of the Coalition, I would also like to acknowledge some of the contributions that Margo made to the disability com­ munity. When she first joined the Board in Febru­ ary 1986, a BCCPD task force was touring the prov­ ince to find out people’s concerns regarding trans­ portation. Two years later, during her first year as BCCPD president, a major goal became a reality when lift-equipped buses were introduced in Vancouver. Margo was president of the BCCPD for seven years. Some of the achievements of the organization during this time include: implementapage 2 • November/December 1997 tion of Section 3.7 of the building code, initiation of the AIDS as a Disability project, the beginning of Advocacy Access, a program which grew from two em­ ployees to the current ten, the introduction of the Mental Health Empower­ ment project, and support for Sue Rodriguez during the very difficult controversy surrounding assisted sui­ cide. Most recently, Margo was a member of the advo­ cate team that successfully lobbied for changes in legis­ lation with respect to GAIN for Handicapped. People know Margo as a warm, genuine person with a love of advocacy and a deep commitment to people with disabilities. She is highly respected within the disability community and, together with her many friends and colleagues, I would like to say “thank you.” Thank you Margo, for your leadership and the countless volunteer hours that you dedicated to plan­ ning strategies, preparing briefs, lobbying, managing the business of the Board, working on committees and attending numerous meet­ ings with individuals, com­ munity groups, non-profit society representatives, government officials and others. Welcome to Vancouver Island and best of luck— wherever your future path may lead. Sincerely, Ronnie Phipps Duncan, BC Latimer Dear Editor: In considering the death of Robert Latimer’s daughter, Tracy, people with disabili­ ties seem to have lost sight of something that is outside of being disabled. Our fight for our rights in so many areas has been long and it is easy to be locked into a way of responding to Tracy’s death, as though we were defending the rights of a disabled person. This blinds us to what we are really defending: the right of a severely suffering young person to be treated with the same compassion as anyone else, regardless of the fact that she is disabled. I am familiar with the condition of being in con­ stant, unendurable suffer­ ing. As a widow with two young children, I was largely bedridden for most of three years. Constant pain when one is a parent can be en­ dured if one can still carry on. But unendurable pain and inability to function is something else. I realized I could not be a parent to my (continued on page 28) E d ito r ia l Transition e’ve all heard the looking at aging with a statistics about disability. One of these is our aging popula­ understanding flow the tion. According to aging process interacts with Health Canada, by the year an existing disability. Some 2016, 16% of Canadians connections will have been be over 65. And, becausemade. we For example, re­ are living longer, more and search is showing that more people will be joining people who have Down’s the ranks of the “middleSyndrome are at higher risk old” (75-84) and the “oldfor developing Alzheimer’s old” (over 85) in the coming disease and are more likely decades. to develop symptoms at a A statistic we don’t hear younger age. Also, according as much about, though, is to the American Association the increasing number of on Mental Retardation, the “aging and disabled.” people who have been tak­ That is, people with disabili­ ing some psychotropic or ties who are growing older anti-seizure drugs for ex­ and older people who are tended periods of time may becoming disabled. be more likely to develop The National Coalition conditions, such as tardive on Disability and Aging in dyskinesia or osteoporosis. the United States has esti­ Overall, though, very mated that approximately little research exists which 85 million people in the U.S. explores the relationship will be aging with disabili­ between aging and disabili­ ties by the year 2000. This ties. Does the aging process is more than the rise of a aggravate particular condi­ new “special interest” group; tions? Are people with cer­ this is an issue which has tain conditions more liable relevance for all of us as we to develop secondary dis­ continue on our way to abilities as they age? This joining the ranks of the “oldgap was highlighted for me old.” while I was searching the It is also a development World Wide Web to research that demands cooperative this article. I came across a efforts between disability web page titled “Cerebral and aging organizations to Palsy and Aging” (http:// ensure that the concerns of WWW. geocities. com /Tokyo / people aging with disabili­ 7970/cpage.htm) and, in­ ties are addressed. stead of the medical and There are a number of social information I was issues that arise when (continued on next page) ■ November/December 1997 • page 3 (Editorial, cont'dfrom previous page) ments do. They also may be expecting, there was a plea discouraged from using from the page owner for services and assistive tech­ more information so that he nologies that could help could post it and share with them maintain their inde­ others. Obviously, there is a pendence and autonomy need for more information because many are geared and it needs to come quickly more to the needs of for those approaching mid­ younger people. We also dle and old age. have to be aware that, as life On the other hand, expectancy increases, so there is much more infor­ does the length of time older mation available about how people will spend living with people can become disabled these disabilities. This as they age. Considerable makes the promotion of more appropriate and sup­ portive attitudes and serv­ ices even more critical. There are many other issues which need to be considered. If more people are aging with disabilities and are living longer, the need for more accessible research exists explaining (and affordable) housing and transportation becomes how vision and hearing even a higher priority. changes, arthritis, osteoporosis, heart disease, Income support is also important for people with stroke, etc. can cause im­ pairments among older disabilities as they age. Some people with disabili­ people. However, since these ties have spent little or no impairments are associated time in the paid work force with aging, they often are dismissed as simply “part of and, as a result, have no getting old” and not consid­ employment pensions to ered distinct disabilities. As draw on when they become a result, older people may seniors. Another problem is not receive the same accept­ personal care/support for ance and support for their people as they age. There Is conditions as younger peo­ a long-standing myth that ple with similar impairfamilies have abandoned Overall, very little research exists which explores the relationship between aging and disabilities. Page 4 • November/December 1997 their oldest members. In fact, according to research done for Health Canada, 8090% of “dependent” seniors are cared for by their fami­ lies, generally spouses and daughters. If supporting people to live in the commu­ nity and in their own homes remains a priority, more effective ways to assist and support their caregivers need to be found. This is especially true when the caregivers themselves are elderly and disabled. This is just a brief over­ view of some of the issues, but I hope that it begins to bring the common ground between people with dis­ abilities and older people into clearer focus. Issues particular to each group should continue to be ad­ dressed separately, but it can only strengthen our collective voice to work together whenever possible. In doing so, we can help ensure that everyone can enjoy an old age character­ ized by dignity, autonomy and respect. Tina Matysiak is a resi­ dential supervisor with a local Community Living Society and is also a gradu­ ate student in social work at the University of British Columbia. ~ Transition AIDS., Aging by Tom Mountford There are many different issues to look at when we consider AIDS and aging. Very little information exists relating directly to the more than 10% of people with HIV infection who are over 50 years of age. Also, the pro­ gression from initial infec­ tion with HIV to full-blown AIDS is a unique aging experience. Along with the successes of the new combi­ nation drug therapies, comes the problems associ­ ated with a growing elderly population disabled by AIDS. For example, the behavioral risks of the eld­ erly have not been dealt with adequately. A study was done by scientists at the University of California, San Francisco and sup­ ported by the National Insti­ tute on Aging and the Na­ tional Institute of Mental Health. It found that older, at-risk heterosexual indi­ viduals are one-sixth as likely to use condoms dur­ ing sex and one-fifth as likely to have been tested for HIV when compared with a group of people in their 20’s who take the same risks, the most prevalent types of behavioral risks reported in this age group were having multiple sexual partners, having a partner with a known behavioral risk or having a blood transfusion before the mid 1980’s. Growing evidence exists that many individuals are sexu­ ally active well into their 80’s and that they seldom use condoms (DeHertough, 1994). However, our ageist society refuses to believe that older people are sexu­ ally active. It was reported in the New York Times (July 31/ 97) that the cases of HIV infection in women over 60 have nearly tripled in the last ten years. The immune systems of these women have slowed down and they often do not see themselves at risk. A decade ago, the majority of infections in women were the result of tainted blood transfusions, while 69% can now be at­ tributed to heterosexual contact. Since women are often not diagnosed, or are misdiagnosed, the statistics available do not reflect the extent of the increasing problem. A surprising 13 of 257 persons (5%) 60-years or older who died in a major New York hospital were found to be undiagnosed HIV positive at the time of their death (El-Sadr & Gettler, 1995). Older HIV-infected individuals deteriorate more rapidly than younger pa­ tients due to an accelerated loss of CD4 helper T-cells. Scientists from Geron Cor­ poration and the UCLA (continued on next page) transition thanks.». We’d like to thank the following people for helping out at our casino fundraising this year. This is a big commitment of volunteer time and their support is much appreciated. Mark Rogen Steve Wong Brian Thomas Mary Ayles May Ng Freda MacLellan Carol Dixon Linda Neumann Tom McGregor page. 6 • November/ December 1997 (AIDS and Aqinq, cant'd from previous paqe) School of Medicine exam­ As baby-boomers in­ ined the immune cells of crease the numbers of those patients with late-stage HIV. over 50, the care and sup­ They found that these cells port of those surviving with had apparently aged to a HIV disease will be challeng­ level similar to those of a ing health-providers and normal 100-year-old person. support organizations. The It appears that the immune support systems of older system is working overtime people with AIDS may not during many years of fight­ include those who are able ing the virus, resulting in to provide the complex and the premature aging of intense care they need. Our certain immune cells. Im­ elders are often a silent mune cell senescence or population and need advo­ aging is a newly described cates. They must not be feature of HIV disease. It forgotten or excluded from has previously been impli­ testing, education and serv­ cated in atherosclerosis, an ices. Research is needed to age-related cardiovascular learn better ways to reduce disease, and may have their risk of infection and implications for therapeutic provide health care that intervention in AIDS. meets their needs. ~ Have a Disability? Need More Money? Disability Benefits from BC Benefits, Ministry of Human Resources: How to apply The booklet, describing how to apply for full disability benefits (level II), is now available on audiotape and on disk (ascii/ text-only version). Order the audiotape and disk from: Legal Services Society Distribution Publishing Program Suite 1500-1140 Pender St. Vancouver, BC V6E 4G1 Fax: (604) 682-0965 The audiotape version is also available on loan from: Crane Resource Centre 1874 East Mall Vancouver, BC V6T1Z1 Tel: (604) 822-6111 Fax: (604) 822-6113 © Legal Services Society, 1997 Latimer Decision Shocks Community Joint statement from BCACL& BCCPD The BC Association for Community Living (BCACL) and the BC Coalition of People with Disabilities (BCCPD) are greatly con­ cerned that the use of a constitutional exemption to reduce Robert Latimer's sentence to two years less a day has put the citizenship rights of Canadians with disabilities into serious question. The unprecedented leniency given Mr. Latimer has signaled that we have taken a giant step toward creating two standards in law-one for Canadians who are deemed to be ablebodied and competent, and another for people with disabilities. Mr. Latimer's original charge of first de­ gree murder had already been reduced to second degree murder, despite the fact that he intentionally murdered his 12-year-old daughter Tracy. We believe that the extraordinary accommoda­ tion now given Mr. Latimer has virtually eclipsed the rights of his daughter and has put the very lives of many children and adults living with disabilities at risk. What does this sentence tell people with disabilities about the value of their lives? What does it say about the vulnerability many people with disabili­ ties now face should an individual, charged with responsibility for their care, decide to end their lives? Tracy Latimer was not dying of her condition, and there is no evidence that she wanted to die. Whatever motivated Mr. Latimer to take it upon himself to kill his daughter, it is critical that society does not allow someone's perceived pain or suffering to become legiti­ mate grounds for murder. Many of the assump­ tions about Tracy's quality of life reflect society's limited understanding about people with disabilities generally and the mythology that surrounds them. Not only did Tracy lose her citizenship rights, but we fear her murder will be used as a lever to erode the rights of others. ~ Comments from the Council of Canadians with Disabilities "The victim's disability did not confer upon her father the right to end her life, nor should it now confer upon the court the right to reduce the manda­ tory sentence called for by the conviction." Eric Norman, Chairperson, CCD "In reducing the sentence, the court is clearly saying that it has sympathy for the con­ victed murderer, and to a chilling degree is validating similar actions against people with disabilities. It is also lending support to the notion that the killing of a person with a disability is different from the killing of any other person. " Hugh Scher, Chairperson, CCD Human Rights Committee November/December 1997 • page 7 Travel Info The Fall 1997 edition of We’re Accessible: News for Wheelchair Travellers is full of travel tips and tales. Stories are included from wheelchair users who travelled to South America, Austria and the no-less-challenging Ottawa. There are also miscellaneous tips and a guide to travel information for people with disabilities on the Internet. For more information, contact Lynn Atkinson, 32 1675 Cypress Street, Vancouver, BC V6J 3L4, tel/fax (604) 731-2197, E-mail lynn@istar.ca COMPREHENSIVE UNIVERSAL DESIGN SERVICES Tel/TT: (604)873-0066 Fax: (604) 873-3145 page 8 • November/December 1997 Deaf Community Wins at Supreme Court In a historic and unanimous decision, the Supreme Court of Canada has ruled that EC’s medical services must include sign language inter­ pretation for Deaf persons. The Court decided that the refusal to fund this service discriminated against Deaf persons on the basis of disability. The Women’s Legal Education and Action Fund (LEAF) and its coali­ tion partner, DAWN Canada: DisAbled Women’s Network Canada, intervened in this case in April of this year to address the effect of the exclusion of sign lan­ guage interpretation on Deaf persons. EC’s courts decided that there was no discrimination because sign language interpretation is not itself a health care service. In a stunning reversal, the Su­ preme Court ruled that a cornerstone for effective medical services is the abil­ ity to communicate with one’s doctor. Communica­ tion cannot be separated from health care. Therefore, to the extent that (hey can­ not communicate with their doctors. Deaf persons re­ ceive substandard health care solely because of their disability. Such differential treatment of Deaf persons is prohibited by the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The law in question did not specifically target Deaf persons for discrimination; it simply did not mention them. The Supreme Court reiterated its earlier rulings that discrimination need not be intentional, but can also arise as a result of “adverse effects.’’ The Supreme Court also acknowledged that people with disabilities will often be negatively affected by legislation that appears neutral. The Supreme Court also clarified when non-govern­ mental organizations must conform to the Charter. Ordinarily, the Charter only applies to provincial and federal governments. EC had argued that because hospitals—not the govern­ ment—provide health serv­ ices, the Charter could not apply. The Supreme Court dismissed this argument and ruled that whenever anybody carries out a gov­ ernment objective, for which it is funded by the govern­ ment, that body must con­ form to the Charter just as the government must. (From Women’s Legal Education and Action Fund (LEAF) - transition Action Needed to Protect Seniors by Scott Adams me Representation Agreement Act, the Health Care and Care Facility Admission Act, the Adult Guardianship Act and the Public Guardian and Trustee Act are all 100% unconstitutional. All four Acts begin by giving “the adult” more or less complete authority concern­ ing his or her affairs, rights and health care. However, they end by saying, in effect, that the Office of the Public Guard­ ian and Trustee (OPGT) can under certain circum­ stances override an adult’s request or decisions. The way it is explained, this sounds reasonable. But in practice, these four acts and the existing Patients Property Act allow and condone the arbitrary confinement and extortion of our elderly citizens-and some who are not so eld­ erly. Many of those who are confined have abso­ lutely nothing wrong with them except a hearing problem or some other minor disability which makes them appear incapa­ ble to the casual observer. My experience is that with age comes wisdom. Some of the things younger people say, think and do seems to prove the point. The Charter and Consti­ tution make it clear that the Patients Property Act is unconstitutional. Our courts should not have the right to take away anyone’s rights on the opinion of any two doctors or psychiatrists. Every Canadian must have the right to refuse medica­ tion or treatment and to leave a hospital or other institution at any time. I believe that the Action Plan for Representation Agreements from the Com­ munity Coalition for the Implementation of Adult Guardianship is the best way to go. However, if the continued on next page November/December 1997 • page 9 Transition (Seniors, cont'd from previous page) friends or relatives, good lawyers, and money. But for Act is not overruled, and the vast majority, the whole specifically, if our courts appeal process is a sham. retain the authority to take So, I am tentatively our rights away as they are suggesting that we hold now doing, even a Represen­ peaceful rallies on a regular tation Agreement will be of basis, perhaps on the first little or no help to most of Saturday of each month. us. Also, we need a campaign of We should not think letter-writing, phone calls, that the conventional legal faxes and e-mails. Hope­ process will be of any help; fully, the daily newspapers our government and courts and talk shows will also join are not going to convict or in and oblige our politicians discipline themselves. Our and courts to act on behalf courts do award certain of our elderly citizens. individuals justice from time I'd also like to clarify a to time, but only to those paragraph in my article that with media attention or was published in the June/ those who have strong July /97 edition of Transi­ tion. A sentence in para­ graph one, page 12 states that, "...our Charter, Consti­ tution, and the Patient's Property Act allow the arbi­ trary confinement of our elderly citizens." With the exception of Section 33, the "notwithstanding" section, our Charter and Constitu­ tion are excellent. If you would like to help, meet with me or get more information, please write to me at: Habitat Canada Box #538 - 1027 Davie St., Vancouver, BC V6E 4L2. - A list of actual English subtitles used in films made in Hong Kong: • I am damned unsatisfied killed in this way. • Fatty, you with your thick face have hurt my instep. • Same old rules: no eyes, no groin. • A normal person wouldn’t steal pituitaries. • Damn, I’ll burn you into a BBQ chicken! • Who gave you the nerve to get killed here? • You always use violence. I should’ve ordered glutinous rice chicken. (From The Sun, Saturday, Oct. 18/97). page 10 • November/December 1997 • I’ll fire aimlessly if you don’t come out! • You daring lousy guy. • Beat him out of recognizable shape! • I have been scared S_ _ _ tless too much lately. • I got knife scars more than the number of your leg’s hair! • Beware! Your bones are going to be disconnected. • The bullets inside are very hot. Why do I feel so cold? • How can you use my intestines as a gift? T R A As you may be aware, the federal government is mak ing various changes to the Canada Pension Plan as a whole. One of the most important changes is around the eligibility criteria for Canada Pension Plan Disability Benefits (CPP Disability). The amount of CPP Disability Benefits a person receives is entirely depend ent on how many years she or he has worked and con trlbuted to the plan. Cur­ rently, the period of time that an applicant must ha worked and contributed to the Plan is two out of the N S I T Changes to CPP What You Need to Know' last three years or five out of the last ten years. As of January 1, 1998 the period of time that a person must have worked and contributed to CPP will be four out of the last six years. This could mean a number of people who are I O N currently eligible for CPP Disability Benefits will not be entitled to benefits. This new legislation will only effect the amount of contributions and the period of time in which the contri­ butions were made. It does not change the disability criteria. At this point, we understand that there will be no changes to the legisla­ tion around incapacity and late applications. If you are in this cat­ egory, and have any ques­ tions, please contact Cindy Marshall or Ted Hobbs at the BCCPD’s Advocacy Access Program. « Parents Launch Human Rights Action by Carol Walshe, Citizen Staff Reporter The parents of a Lake Cowichan girl with a medi­ cal condition that requires catheterization have launched a human rights complaint against School District 79. Kevin and Fiona Law­ rence maintain their daugh­ ter’s rights have been vio­ lated by the school district and allege bureaucratic procedures have taken precedence over her health. Six year old Kristi Law- bifida, and requires cath­ eterization three times daily. The process involves insert­ ing a sterile tube into the urethra to allow her to relieve herself. The aid Kristi became comfortable with in Kinder­ garten is certified to catheterize her. Her parents wrote to Dr. Ed Armstrong of SD 79 in June, outlining Kristi’s medical condition and asking that the aid she was comfortable with con- received no reply to the letter. Kevin Lawrence says he and his wife had no idea how the school district’s hiring processes worked, and assumed that the na­ ture of Kristi’s case would guarantee special considera­ tion. A district wide “cattle call’’ at which teacher’s aides and assistants are given an opportunity to choose assignments with (continued on next page) November/December 1997 • page 11 {Parents, cont'd from previous page) particular students resulted something as personal as a in an aide with more senior­ catheterization on her.” ity from the former District Armstrong and Alastair 65 being assigned to Kristi. Ferguson, special services The new aide, a former district principal, acknowl­ nurse, is fully qualified to edge the role played by amalgamation in the bump­ catheterize Kristi. Described by her parents as a sensitive ing of Kristi’s aide. Both child unwilling to allow a agree that if the job selec­ relative stranger to catheter­ tion process had been done ize her, Kristi has stead­ according to the old school fastly refused to allow the district boundaries, the aide new aid to perform the Kristi had in Kindergarten catheterization.... “Kristi has been severely Lawrence traumatized by years of poking and prodding,” said maintain their daughters rights Fiona Lawrence. “It’s unre­ alistic to expect her to allow have been violated by the just anyone to perform Kevin and Fiona school district and allege bureaucratic procedures have taken precedence over her health. would likely have stayed assigned to her.... Kevin and Fiona Law­ rence say the bureaucratic aspects of the case don’t interest them. They say their primary concern is for the health of their child. “Seniority and the col­ lective bargaining process are endangering our child,” said Kevin Lawrence. “If she is not catheterized regularly, she could develop a bladder page 12 • November/December 1997 infection and be in hospital getting IV antibiotics for ten days.”... Armstrong says the school district has some discretionary powers, but is ultimately bound by hiring practices dictated by the collective agreement with CUPE. “The situation is akin to that found in a hospital,” he said. “In a hospital, you have no choice about which nurse cares for you.” Ferguson says he un­ derstands the concerns of the family, but sees no way around the terms of the collective agreement. “I don’t have the answer to this,” he said.... Kevin and Fiona Law­ rence expect the human rights suit could take up to 18 months to be settled. “We don’t have that kind of time. Kristi’s progress has already been set back a year. She was getting to the point where she was begin­ ning to feel comfortable about herself, and learning to catheterize herself, but now that’s all been set back.” The family is investigat­ ing further action against the school district. (from the Duncan Citizen, Sunday, Nov. 9/97). ~ Government Backtracks on Education Cuts The provincial government had planned funding cut­ backs for people with dis­ abilities seeking post-second ary education. Lobbying by BCCPD and others resulted in a reversal of the decision. The following is from a letter sent to Tom McGregor at BCCPD from the office of David Mitchell, Manager of Vocational Rehabilitation Services. I am writing to thank you and your organization for your valued input into proposed changes to Voca­ tional Rehabilitation Serv­ ices (VRS) operational policy over the recent past months and to advise you that, although we will not be introducing any changes to VRS policy at this time, we are continuing to explore opportunities to expand community-based services and through these, address the growing demand for services. Over the past few weeks, the Honourable Paul Ramsey, Minister of Educa- tion, Skills and Training, has been actively lobbying the federal government on the issue of post-secondary student debt. As a result of these discussions, the Min­ istry has decided to put on hold any changes to VRS policy that would require students with a disability to seek Student Financial Aid funding for post-secondary education. This decision may be reviewed after the federal government has had an opportunity to respond to the many calls for greater post-secondary student funding assistance. VRS is committed to assisting people with dis­ abilities to access the goods and services necessary for education, skills training and employment. Our goal is to provide services to more people next year than we have this year. In order to accomplish this, we will need your help. It is our intention to expand our current partnerships wit h agencies and contractors, and to develop new services for people with disabilities as much as our current budget and program allow. We recognize there will be some challenges as VRS seeks ways to improve its service delivery system. (continued on next page) Mothers who have lost custody of their offspring due to mental illness can meet other Moms of like mind and situation for coffee meetings. We share experiences and interests and create friendships. We hope together to lessen the burden of living without our offspring. We meet one-to-one with Dawn and as a group. For more information, call Dawn at 871-0151. November/December 1997 • page 13 (Government, cont'dfrom previous page) Some of the steps that VRS will be taking over the com­ ing months include: • Development of new VRS and Student Serv­ ices Branch program brochures that will provide people with a disability and service providers with up-todate information on what is available through these two fund­ ing sources. • VRS and its Community Partners will work with Special Needs Coordina­ tors in Colleges to en­ sure that students have support to secure fund­ ing and other assistance needed to participate in post-secondary educa­ tion. • The Ministry of Educa­ tion, Skills and Training will be conducting a formative evaluation of VRS to determine the effectiveness of our delivery model and to recommend changes to improve the level and quality of service being provided. Thank you for your continued support. ~ page 14 • November/December 1997 HEALTH CENTRE FOR CHILDREN The Sexual Health Resource Network (SHRN) is a provincial Service which includes: • Directory of Service Providers • Training and Education • Resource and Information Library the main goals of the SHRN are: • (o increase’ (he understanding of healthy sexual development among Children and young people with disabilities, and • to ensure those who have* e*xperienced sexual abuse will have* access to information about available services. You can reach the SHRN by: Mail Sunny Hill Health centre for Children Sexual Health resource Network Slocan street, Vancouver, BC VSM 3E8 Phone: I 8003311533 toll free across Canada) 16044341331General Information) fax: 1604431 7395 E-mail: mharber@sunnyhill.bc.ca Transition There are about 140 million disa­ bled children In the world. 97% of disabled children In poor countries have no rehabilitation. 98% are without education. 90% ofdisabled children will not survive beyond the age of five. This horrible list of statistics about disabled children opened the The­ matic Day of the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child on Octo­ ber 6. The members of the Committee on the Rights of the Child looked at the right of disabled children to life, development, inclusion and self-representation. There were two of us who had been disabled children; there were parents of disabled children, and, for the first time ever at such a meeting, there were two young girls from South Africa who spoke about their own experiences. Pearl, deafened by riot­ ing in Soweto, spoke of her loneliness and isolation from her hearing friends. Chantal told how she' and her family had had to move from their home to the city Report on the Committee on the Rights of the Child: Disabled Children so that she could get medi­ cal support, crutches and an education. They had both experi­ enced the stigma that is attached to disabled chil­ dren and their families. They had experienced the poverty and difficulties in just trying to lead an ordi­ nary life. Family members spoke with passion about the stigma and fear which give society the excuse to sup­ port eugenic laws of abor­ tion and sterilisation. We all spoke about (he huge numbers of disabled children who are abused and abandoned, whose rights to life and inclusion are violated on a massive ' scale. The Committee set up a working group which will include representatives of international disability organizations. The Commit­ tee will monitor what coun­ tries are doing for disabled children when they do their regular work of looking at member states’ reports on their implementation of the Convention on the Rights of the Child. They stressed that all articles of the Convention impact on disabled children and must be monitored accordingly. They have issued a statement which says that the violation of the right to life was the worst discrimination and abuse faced by anyone. Their statement calls for governmental and legal action. But above all they called for an end to the stigma and a Celebration of diversity. It is up to all of us to ensure that our govern­ ments take action and that disabled children take their rightful place within their families and their communi­ ties. (From Disability Awareness in Action, November 1997, by Rachel Hurst ). ~ November/December 1997 • page 15 Your Membership is Valuable helping agencies depend on government funding and fear funding cuts. They need an independent advocate like the Coalition to lobby for their interests. The B.C. Coalition of People with Disabilities is a province-wide, non-profit organization run by and for people with disabilities. We are an umbrella group representing all people with disabilities and our strength comes from membership support. • Will you join the Coalition today and help build the voice for people with disabilities? policy research and development on areas of concern to you. • membership voting rights, if you are a person witfl a disability. As soon as you begin your membership, you'll enjoy a number of benefits: • an organization that can lobby the government on behalf of people with disabilities-too many If you would like more information on BCCPD, please feel free to contact the office at the address below, or call (604) 875-0188. t^^^ways thought that life after 50 would be meaningful climbing the Mountain of Aging By Barbara Alldrit Illustration by Maria George and productive. I’d travel, write stories inspired by my life’s experience and devote more time to good causes. In the meantime, however, I had a list of goals to achieve in my career, education, fitness and wilderness adventures. One of these goals was climbing Mount Kilimanjaro. Then three years ago, at 41, I was diagnosed with multi­ ple sclerosis. It was said to be chronic progressive MS which has no “cure”, only drug therapy for acute symptoms. In other words, I was told the odds were that my health and functional ability would continue to decline, although I should still have a near-normal life expectancy. Assimilating this information, and my creeping func­ tional losses, forced me to come to terms with my own mor­ tality and the knowledge that my body was aging much faster than normally expected (one naturopathic doctor told me my biological age was 65). I realized that if I maintained my achievement-oriented mindset, and accepted my prognosis as presented, I would have to use my declining energy to “fast track” those goals still within my abilities. Alternatively, I could put my list aside and simply try to live well each day, looking outside of the conventional medical system for therapeutic approaches that would restore my shatby genetics (for people with tered sense of hope and MS this figure is 25%). The control in my me. I chose remainder, however, is the latter course. related to environmental My choice was influ­ factors, such as air and enced initially by my socio­ water quality, to lifestyle logical education which had choices such as diet and taught me that the determi­ exercise, and to social fac­ nants of health have more to tors, such as whether one do with lifestyle choices and has an adequate income, a social factors than with the sense of purpose and a offerings of the dominant supportive network of family “drugs-and-surgery” ori­ and friends. ented medical care system. These factors resonated Statistically, access to with memories of my mother our “high tech” medical care who was a lifelong devotee system explains only 12 to of what is now known as 25% of the collective health “alternative” or “complementary status of Canadians. An­ ” medicine. She was a other 12% can be explained (continued on next page) November/December 1997 • page 17 T R A N S I T (Mountain, cont'dfrom previous page) only essential to recovery traditional healer who un­ from injury and chronic derstood the healing powers illness, it is one of the best of foods, herbs, hot baths anti-aging strategies as and vinegar packs, as well well—and that it is never too as the power of love and late to start. Getting regular prayer. Her wisdom and exercise for strength, flex­ skills were often the first ibility and aerobic capacity option for many with aches is more challenging with a and pains in the small Mennonite farming commu­ nity where I grew up. My mother insisted I take a tablespoon of cod liver oil and a handful of vitamin and mineral rich stress kelp and malt tablets every reduction, day no matter how foul they tasted to me. Science is now proving that daily supple­ mentation with a vitamin and mineral tablet boosts having the immune system, and that a deficiency of the team omega 3 essential fatty acids, abundantly present in disability, but not impossi­ ocean fish (including the ble, as I am learning. infamous cod liver oil) and My mother believed in flax seeds are a factor in the redemptive powers of many debilitating chronic the practice of hope, love illnesses including MS. and prayer. Many scientiflc My mother insisted that studies are now demonstrat­ helping her plant, nurture ing the health restoring and harvest our five acre effects of stress reduction, garden (which also provided meditation, support groups, an abundance of organic creative visualization, spir­ vegetables) was good for itual beliefs and simply both of us. Science is con­ having faith in one's health tinuously validating the fact care team and therapies. that regular exercise is not Many scientific studies are now demonstrating the health restoring effects of meditation, support groups, creative visualization, spiritual beliefs and simply faith in one's health care and therapies. page 18 • November/December 1997 I O N We need to redefine health care to include all these elements: therapeutic choices that put the indi­ vidual, not the expert, in control; a clean environ­ ment; a secure and ad­ equate income; and, a soci­ ety structured to value its members and provide a sense of connection and purpose. I hope to see the day when my neighbourhood health clinic will provide nutritional balancing, thera­ peutic touch, massage, energy balancing, yoga classes, and psychological and spiritual counselling, along with antibiotics and wound stitching. Right now, this is just a pipe dream, but at one time, so was universal access to hospi­ talization and medical care. Collective action changed (hat. I don’t know what the future holds, but I still plan to climb Mt. Kilimanjaro one day. My mother always said that luck favours prepared ground, so it’s up to me to use the power of my own thoughts and actions to redirect my health. She also said that every problem has a solution. And if my own T R A N S I T I O N legs won’t cany me up Mount Kilimanjaro, there is always the option of hiring porters to do the job for me. In any event, that’s where 1 plan to be for my fiftieth birthday on March 1, 2003. Whatever my future holds as 1 approach my second half-century, 1 be­ lieve the lessons of my dis­ ability have given me the grace to accept the inevita­ ble aging of my body earlier than many. It has also taught me that I am in control of making that proc­ ess as painless and fulfilling as possible. ~ Network Closes The Inclusion Resource Network (IRN) is no longer available for consultative services for educators and parents of children with special needs. After three years of operation, the BC Ministry of Education has decided not to continue funding this service. However, the BC Teachers’ Federation will continue to update the IRN Homepage which includes the opportunity to browse the IRN database. Watch for the Elementary Modified and Adapted Materials database to also be online. After October 1997, the IRN database will not be updated. Some of the materials that were distributed through the IRN will be available for purchase through the BCTF Lesson Aids Service. See their online catalogue through the BCTF’s Web site (www.bctf.bc.ca). November/December 1997 • page 19 Planning a Safe and Secure Future page 20 • November/December 1997 Many people haven’t heard of the Planned Lifetime Advocacy Network (PLAN). We’re often asked, “Who is PLAN?” and “What do you do?” Maybe the best way to answer these questions is to tell a story. Consider the story of John. John was a healthy and active boy living in the lower mainland of B.C. In addition to the many interests young boys have John was a mountain bike enthusiast. John rode his bike everywherc. No hole was deep enough, no curb high enough. One (lay during John’s 12111 year, he collided with a transport truck.,John sus­ tained severe head and spinal eord injuries. John’s injuries were so severe spent th(* r<‘st of his adoles­ cence in Sunny Hill Hospi­ tal. He was unable* to speak or move any part of his body, except bls month, and was completely dependent on others for all of his care. His family, overwhelmed by the loss of their healthy son, and their inability to com­ municate with him, eventu ally stopped visiting. John became increasingly lonely and isolated. Fortunately, a visitor to the hospital noticed John and told PLAN about him. Members of PLAN met with John and, shortly thereaf­ ter, PLAN “adopted” John. We developed a circle of caring and committed indi­ viduals, enrolled John in school again, and eventually moved him back into the community. PLAN has made a lifetime commitment to John—to advocate for him, to monitor his quality of life, and to maintain his circle of support. John is now 26 years old. He enjoys laughing, joking, loud music and watching sports, especially hockey. His great gift is a winning smile and his abil­ ity to draw people into a relationship with him. With Plan’s help, John has affected many people and in return many people have affected him. This is one example of what PLAN does. PLAN works with fami­ lies who have a relative with a disability. The group was formed in 1989 by a group of senior parents of adult children with disabilities. These parents recognized that the closure of institu­ tions and the re-introduc­ tion of individuals with disabilities back into com­ munity meant many parents were the primary supports for their adult children with a disability. These parents also acknowledged their own aging and realized they would need a plan to ensure Most importantly, we develop and maintain circles of support which surround the individual with a disability with caring and supportive people. a safe and secure future for their son or daughter with a disability when they were no longer around to care for and advocate for them. These parents also shared a common desire—to establish a system of sup­ port independent of govern­ ment whereby the care provided to their sons and daughters would not depend upon the goodwill of politi- cians. They also believed service providers need to be regularly monitored and held accountable, and that those attempting to hold government accountable could not themselves be­ come reliant upon govern­ ment for their own financial survival. As a result, the founding members of PLAN resolved to provide services for adults with disabilities without the financial sup­ port of the government. PLAN is unique in other ways too. We are the only organization which plans for the future. PLAN designs and offers services to pro­ vide a safe and secure fu­ ture for individuals with a disability. We advise families on will and estate planning, assist in identifying and securing housing options, including home ownership for an individual with a disability. Most importantly, we develop and maintain circles of support which surround the individual with a disability with caring and supportive people. Plan monitors the quality of services provided to an individual with a disability and advocates on his or her behalf when necessary. And we will provide these serv­ ices for the life of the indi­ vidual with a disability. This is just what those senior parents wanted when they first met in 1989. PLAN has grown over the years. We now provide advice and assistance to over 3,200 families across Canada. We have 450 PLAN associates and maintain circles of support for 42 individuals. And these num­ bers are growing daily. If you are aware of a family who might benefit from PLAN’S expertise and serv­ ices, give them our phone number. You may also consider purchasing a copy of our book. Safe and Secure. The book outlines six steps relatives should consider, as well as seven worksheets and an appendix of re­ sources for securing the future of an individual with a disability. For more information, contact PLAN at 10IB 3790 Canada Way, Burnaby, BC V5G 1G4 or phone (604) 439-9566. « November/December 1997 • page 21 Transition Board Members Retire at AGM \t our AGM this year, two long-time BCCPD Board Members resigned. Margo Massie and John Maddison have both been with the BCCPD for so long, during so many important times, they will be greatly missed. In the fall of 1979, John Maddison was introduced to the BCCPD through his work with Jill Weiss on transportation issues. This work led to the creation of the handyDART custom transit service. During his many years as a Board Member, John has held various positions on the Executive Committee. He was also a member of the Human Rights Committee of the Coalition of Provincial Organizations of page 22 • November/December 1997 the Handicapped, now known as CCD. John will continue his work on transportation issues as Chair of COMPACT, the Committee to Promote Accessible Conventional Transit, and as a Board Member of Pacific transit Cooperative. John's wisdom and clarity of thought-and that distinctive voice-will be missed by all of us. Ronnie Phipps' Letter to the Editor in this edition is a very fitting tribute to our other retiring Board Member, Margo Massie. Margo has filled numerous roles at BCCPD over the years, and has been a tireless and dedicated voice for people with disabilities on many issues. BCCPD was honoured to have her as Chair for many years and, through her work and sincerity Margo became a respected figure both within the disability community and government. Perhaps most of all, we all remember Margo's warmth and humour, and wish her all the best in her well-deserved retirement. We know that Margo will continue to be involved in the community in her new home on the island. The BCCPD Board of Directors would like to thank John and Margo for the years of support they've given us and the disability communities. Mission Statement The BC Coalition of People with Disabilities was founded upon the belief that: people with disabilities want and are entitled to equal opportunities in all the activities and privileges that other Canadians take for granted, full Inclusion of people with disabilities within our JOB PLACEMENT PROGRAM Are you looking for work? Do you have any type of disability? Our program has been developed to assist you in securing quality employment or reaching other vocational goals, such as further education. communities is a fundamental necessity for a diverse, We provide funding for education and transportation. product ive and economically vibrant social WHO QUALIFIES? environment, and • people with disabilities have the right to expect equality, fair treatment and respect • Because of these beliefs, the purposes of the BC Coalition of People with Disabilities are; to use educat ion, advocacy and special projects to WHAT ARE THE BENEFITS? • work toward the dissolution of the physical, attitudinal and systemic barriers in our society that deny us equal opportunities, to provide a st rong coherent voice for the cross­ • • • • disability communities in B C., to share information with and support other self-help disability organizations with common goals, and to carry out our mission and projects within a self­ help model. Anyone who has a barrier to employment such as a disability. You must live in the New Westminster or Burnaby Area. • Professional Resume and Career Counselling We find your next employer. Funding for education. Funding for transportation. Funding for a special modification to the worksite you may need to do your new job. All services are free! WHERE? BC Rehabilitation and Recovery Centre #208 - 88 10th Street New Westminster, BC VSM 6FI8 Tel: 520-3468 Fax: 520-6240 November/December 1997 • page 23 Transition Aging with a SPiNAL CURD Injury by Coleen Heenan. MS, RN page 24 • November/December 1997 Aging with a spinal cord injury (SCI) is a relatively new occurrence. Due to highly technical and devel­ oped health care, a person with a SCI is not only ex­ pected to survive the early years, but is in the unique position of having to cope with growing older. For the first time, this population is experiencing aging-related concerns. Now that people are not dying from medical problems related to their disability (renal problems and pressure areas), they are experiencing problems related to normal aging, as well as problems related to aging with a disability. Aging is not necessarily a medical problem or a sickness that needs to be treated. It is a new stage in life and with this new stage comes changes in physical function and changes in people’s lives. Planning for changes in lifestyle and care needs can help maintain a sense of control and ease about the future. People are noticing physical changes the longer they live with a SCI. Fatigue and chronic exhaustion, for example, associated with reduced energy are common complaints. People are finding they need to pace their daily activities and often need to reduce the number of activities in a given day. This might mean rescheduling daily activities so important things are done earlier in the day, cutting back hours of work or getting assistance with personal care so there is energy left over for spending time with family and friends. There may be a need to re-think their dayto-day lives and focus on putting energy into the things that are most mean­ ingful. Muscle pain and joint pain are also common com­ plaints. Wrist and shoulder wear-and-tear from years of doing adapted repetitive tasks, such as pushing a wheelchair, can affect func­ tion. Many people find rest and change in routine help­ ful in relieving pain. Doing things differently, however, may mean altering equip­ ment and mobility tech­ niques to decrease discom­ fort and prevent further problems. For example, switching to a power chair. TRANSItion a van with a hydraulic lift, a sliding board for transfers, or a manual chair for those who previously walked. Adapting to age-related changes and decreased function is not easy for people to accept. Change that results in an altered lifestyle may Increase emo­ tional distress. An individu­ als’s sense of self-reliance can be threatened by a fear of loss of independence. In addition, people may have feelings of failure or “giving in” to the disability. For others, their quality of life becomes the issue. Declining function and energy can threaten a life­ time of self-confidence. As all of us age, we become set tn our ways, less tolerant of change in routine, environ­ ment and companions. Therefore, as physical func­ tions decrease, we resist new equipment, new proce­ dures, new ways of doing old things at a time when we need to be open to making changes in our way of doing things. Understanding the importance of making changes early can increase people’s quality of life. Find­ ing new ways of doing old things requires great cour­ age, but allows people to do more with less pain, less fatigue and more mobility, resulting in more independ­ ence. A person’s level of per­ ceived control over their life also correlates with meas­ ures of well-being. Research has found that those living with a disability for twenty or more years perceived their lives to be as good as the able-bodied population. Environmental factors can also play a significant role in how well people age. These factors include in­ come, transportation, family and interpersonal supports, and availability of assist­ ance for personal care needs (continued on next page) November/December 1997 • page 25 T (Spinal Cord Injury, cont'd from previous page) if required. The majority of people with physical dis­ abilities are on fixed in­ comes, so growing financial demands are a serious concern for individuals trying to maintain inde­ pendence. For example, shoulder pain and weakness from years of overuse may lead to a decreased ability to maneuver a manual wheel­ chair; however, a power chair is an expensive alter­ native. Increasing economic constraints can be another worry for people trying to adapt to changes accompa­ nying the aging process. Dealing with disability takes time and energy. With aging comes a decrease in both. Priorities must change. People who have survived many years with disability are not just lucky, they are capable, resource­ ful, knowledgeable individu­ als who know their bodies and take responsibility for themselves. (Coleen Heenan is the Canadian Coordinator of BC Rehab's Spinal Cord Pro­ gram). ~ page 26 • November/December 1997 S ' Planning with a Representation Agreement many people think about making a will—taking care of their affairs after they the—but they don’t plan for what might happen if they are alive, but unable to manage their affairs. Powers of attorney, which many people make, only apply to legal and financial matters. They do not cover personal and health care decisions such as consent for medical treat­ ment or admission to an extended care facility. Representation agree­ ments do. They are a new type of legal document in B.C. that allow adults to name someone they trust to represent them if they should need help managing their affairs. The agreements are flexible, allowing repre­ sentatives to help out tem­ porarily, permanently, or on an as-needed basis. The agreements can also Include statements of your beliefs and priorities, or important instructions. Don Beddows, a senior from White Rock, Is one of the volunteers with the new Representation Agreement Resource Centre, currently housed at BCCPD. Don meets with individuals and groups to give them infor­ mation about representation agreements. “I used to be immortal and invulnerable,” explains Beddows. ‘‘But once you get past 70, life gets to be quite dangerous. It is vital to be able to pre-plan not just wills and funerals, but the sorts of care we need and decisions that might have to be made on our behalf.” For people who have extensive contact with the health care system, it is particularly important to appoint a representative for health care. Although many people do make written plans such as living wills, pieces of paper are not as effective as a person you trust, who can be on the spot talking to the medical staff when you are unable to speak for yourself. Your health care repre­ sentative has legal access to medical records and legal “clout” in decision making. Your representative can ask questions, demand explana­ tions, explain your wishes and defend your rights. transition B.C.’$ Representation Agreement Act has not yet been proclaimed, but people are already making and using representation agree­ ments now, and getting them ready for when the law is proclaimed. The Representation Agreement Resource Centre was founded by the Com­ munity Coalition for the Implementation of Adult Guardianship Legislation which includes BCCPD, the BC Association for Commu­ nity Living, the Alzheimer Society and the Council of Senior Citizens Organiza­ tions. The Resource Centre is a volunteer-driven non­ profit society which assists people to make representa­ tion agreements. The Centre offers workshops for com­ munity groups, and training for community advocates and peer counsellors on how to help others to make representation agreements. For more information on the Representation Agree­ ment Resource Centre, contact Donna McMahon or Christine Gordon c/o BCCPD at 875-0188. « Want to start your own multi-million dollar business, plus put people to work? My wife and I have invented and patented a padded "Street Hockey Suit." With this Suit, plus wearing elbow and knee pads, helmet and cup-and your favorite NHL team jersey-you will be fully protected. You can use a regular hockey ball without fear of bruises and welts. Because I have a disability, we are not able to start our own business. So, we are selling the patent for the "Street Hockey Suit." Part of the proceeds of the sale will go to the BC Coalition of People with Disabilities. A proto­ type has been made and tested-the kids love it. Please contact Joanne and David Gray, phone or fax (604) 572-8539. THe BUSH To Moses tell me Birkenstocks November/December 1997 • page 27 Transition Norma's will continue to accept new ads as usual by phone, letter or email. These will be posted to the Internet as soon as received. Ten dollar ads will appear in the next printed issue, so, in effect, one-month ads will be valid for up to three months. To encourage email ads, I am offering free one-month ads (Internet only—print version not included) throughout this period. NIDEC’S ads will continue to be free for viewing on the internet. Our address is http://www.lights.com/ classifieds/This list will be updated every Thursday and so will remain an up-to-date service. NIDEC is a service dedicated to helping people with disabilities buy the equipment they need at a reasonable price, or sell/exchange used disability equipment. You can contact NIDEC at Norma’s Independence & Disability Equipment Classifieds (NIDEC), 269 Carleton Dr., Saskatoon, Sask. S7H 3P1, Tel/fax: (306) 955-0071, Classified Ad For sale; electric, adjustable bed. Remote controlled. Double size. Excellent condition; very clean. $800. Call 985-3730 (evenings). page 28 • November/December 1997 (Letters, cont'd from p. 2) children, nor could I endure the untreatable pain (my doctors had made a decision not to do further surgery). I planned my own death to liberate me and my children who could then be adopted and have a chance for nor­ mal lives. A sudden emer­ gency changed my plan and I was rushed to hospital. My doctors then decided they would do a further drastic operation. Due to unantici­ pated complications, I am now permanently disabled, but I am free of all pain. I now have a worthwhile life. Tracy’s situation was far worse than mine and for so many more years of her short life. When one has experienced the pain that I did, then one is able to speak with the knowledge of what she was going through. It is true that more community support could have helped Tracy’s coura­ geous parents, but Tracy’s worsening condition could not be alleviated by further medical intervention. I don’t doubt that her loving parents knew, with­ out her being able to talk, that it was her wish to cease her anguished living. It is true that our compassion is aroused when we think of her and hear the details of her life. It is aroused, not because she is disabled, but because of her unbearable life. It is simply ignorance that equates suffering with disability. This is not neces­ sarily true, as I know so well. Yours truly, Daphne Naegele Vancouver, BC Dear Editor: We should all be grateful to the Saskatchewan jury who convicted Robert Latimer for the murder of his 12 yearold daughter Tracy. That conviction not only affirmed that all members of our society have intrinsic value—in the end, it meant that Tracy died a “citizen.” We at the BC Associa­ tion for Community Living do not underestimate the obstacles many parents of children with disabilities face in attempting to secure opportunities, support services, and an acceptable quality of life for their sons and daughters. However, regardless of Robert Latimer’s personal feelings or motivations at the time, it is clear that he murdered his daughter without her consent. Acting entirely outside the law, he took away Tracy’s funda­ mental right to live. The fact that Tracy lived with a dis­ ability does not, and should not, lessen the crime. T R A We will never know what Tracy Latimer would have wanted for herself. But we assume we know. We assume her needs outweighed her gifts. We assume her pain outweighed her joy. We assume that because she could not speak for herself she was neither intelligent, nor thoughtful, nor talented. And perhaps, most disturb­ ing of all, we assume her death was a liberation. Viewed this way, is it not we who are confined by our severe Ignorance and profound misunderstanding of who Tracy Latimer was? Is it not we who suffer in our limited understanding of who she was and who she may have become? And in the wake of her death, is it not our ability to grow and reach for the stars that is now truly at stake? Should Latimer and his supporters now be success­ ful in their bid to weaken Canada’s existing murder laws, not only will Tracy’s citizenship be put into ques­ tion—so will the citizenship of all those Canadians who live with disabling condi­ tions. We should all think twice before allowing Tracy’s murder to be used as a lever to erode the rights of others. If we don’t, the unfortunate, N S I T legacy of Tracy’s death will be to have put any one of us who experience pain or who require multiple surgeries at the individual mercy of those who are charged with our care and well being. Our collective challenge now is not to find a way to make murder easier. The challenge is to change those attitudes and assumptions that are based on lack of knowledge and fear of differ­ ence. We must be willing to discover and learn about the abilities, dreams and wishes of those who have been labelled profoundly handi­ capped. We must be willing to put an end to the isola­ tion and lack of support experienced by people with disabilities and their fami­ lies, and we must be willing to ensure that those who are vulnerable enjoy the same fundamental human rights afforded all citizens in this country. Without commitments such as these, we will con­ tinue to put those who are deemed less valuable at risk and we will have lost a tremendous opportunity to transform perceptions based on “pity” into actions based on “respect.” Anita Dadson, President B.C. Association for Community Living Vancouver, BC « I O N resources women with Disabilities We came across some information about a doctor who is doing research around menopause, osteoporosis and women with disabilities. Unfortunately, we heard about her just as Transition was going to print. If you would like more information in this area, please contact: Dr. Sandra Weiner, MD, 8484 16th Street, Suite 707, Silver Spring, MD 20910, Tel: (301) 587-6396, Fax: (301) 585-5467, Email: welnersmd@aol. com People with Developmental Disabilities In July 1996, the BC Association for Community Living held a Forum on Aging and People with Developmental Disabilities. A 30-page report, including recommendations, is available. For information, contact BCACL at #300 - 30 East 6th Avenue, Vancouver, BC V5T 4P4, Tel. (604) 875-1119, fax (604) 875-6744. November/December 1997 • page 29